5428 CRB-8-09-2 (2010). Francis v. Rushford Centers, Inc.
Court | Connecticut |
Connecticut Workers Compensation
2010.
5428 CRB-8-09-2 (2010).
Francis v. Rushford Centers, Inc
CASE NO. 5428
CRB-8-09-2COMPENSATION REVIEW
BOARD
WORKERS' COMPENSATION COMMISSIONFEBRUARY 8, 2010MARIE C. FRANCIS CLAIMANT-APPELLEE v.
RUSHFORD CENTERS, INC. EMPLOYER and WORKERS COMPENSATION TRUST INSURER
RESPONDENTS-APPELLANTS APPEARANCES: The claimant was represented by Douglas L.
Drayton, Esq., Pomeranz, Drayton and Stabnick, 95 Glastonbury Boulevard,
Glastonbury, CT 06033. The respondents were represented by Neil J. Ambrose,
Esq., Letizia, Ambrose and Falls, P.C., One Church Street, 4th Floor, New
Haven, CT 06510. This Petition for Review from the January 26, 2009 Finding and
Award of the Commissioner acting for the Eighth District was heard August 28,
2009 before a Compensation Review Board panel consisting of the Commission
Chairman John A. Mastropietro and Commissioner Peter C. Mlynarczyk and Randy L.
Cohen. OPINIONJOHN A. MASTROPIETRO, CHAIRMAN. This
case requires us to consider the applicability of the apportionment statute,
§ 31-349 C.G.S. in a case where the claimant's initial injury occurred in
another state. The claimant was injured again in Connecticut and the trial
commissioner has ordered the respondents to pay the full value of the
claimant's permanent partial disability. The respondents have appealed from the
trial commissioner's Finding and Award. They argue that the compensation for
the claimant's initial injury was "payable" from that prior injury and
therefore, they should not be responsible for any permanency benefits
attributable to that prior injury. Our review, however, indicates that the
claimant does not have as of this date any clear right to compensation for
permanent partial disability from that initial injury. Since there was no prior
award which would be "payable" under the terms of Chapter 568, we affirm the
trial commission's decision on this issue. We do however, find the respondents
had a reasonable basis to contest this matter, and reverse the trial
commissioner's order of sanctions. In all other respects, we dismiss this
appeal.
The trial commissioner found the following facts which are
pertinent to our appellate review. The commissioner found that the claimant,
Marie Francis, sustained an injury to her lumbar spine on August 6, 2006 while
employed by the respondent, Rushford Centers, Inc. The parties have reached a
voluntary agreement for this injury approved on February 5, 2007. The claimant
had suffered an earlier lumbar spine injury on June 29, 1998 while employed in
the State of Arizona. The claimant has been treating with Dr. W. Jay
Krompinger. In 2001 Dr. Krompinger opined "I believe that her work injury
sustained on June 29, 1998 predominantly caused exacerbation of the
degenerative changes and internal disc structure. . ." and opined that the
claimant had reached maximum medical improvement with a 20% permanent partial
impairment of the lumbar spine.
The claimant filed a claim in Arizona for her 1998 injury. Under
Arizona law, unlike Chapter 568, the lumbar spine is not among the enumerated
body parts which constitute a "scheduled injury." On February 12, 2002, the
Industrial Commission of Arizona concluded the claimant was not entitled to
receive permanent partial disability benefits for this lumbar injury.
Following her injury in Arizona the claimant returned to full
time employment as a psychiatric nurse. She treated with Dr. Krompinger
following her 2006 injury. On December 20, 2006 Dr. Krompinger issued a report
discussing the claimant's various lumbar spine injuries and concluded . . . I
think for all practical purposes, I would consider her pain complex at present
to be an exacerbation of her previous lumbar fusion." Dr. Krompinger referred
the claimant to Dr. Pietro Memmo. Dr. Memmo opined on September 18, 2007 that
the claimant had suffered a disc herniation at the L3-4 level, a separate level
than her previous injury. As a result of this injury, Dr. Memmo opined "she...
To continue reading
Request your trial