5439 CRB-4-09-2 (2010). Volmut v. General Electric Company.
Court | Connecticut |
Connecticut Workers Compensation
2010.
5439 CRB-4-09-2 (2010).
Volmut v. General Electric Company
CASE NO. 5439
CRB-4-09-2COMPENSATION REVIEW
BOARD
WORKERS' COMPENSATION COMMISSIONAPRIL 7, 2010VINCENT C. VOLMUT CLAIMANT-APPELLEE CROSS-APPELLANT
v. GENERAL ELECTRIC COMPANY EMPLOYER and SEDGWICK CMS, INC. INSURER and
ELECTRIC INSURANCE COMPANY INSURER RESPONDENTS-APPELLANTS CROSS-APPELLEES
APPEARANCES: The
claimant was represented by Robert F. Carter, Esq., Carter and Civitello, One
Bradley Road, Suite 301, Woodbridge, CT 06525. The respondents were represented
by Nicholas W. Francis, Esq., Law Offices of Jonathan M. Zajac, LLC, 152
Simsbury Road, P.O. Box 699, Avon, CT 06001. This Petition for Review from the
February 20, 2009 Finding and Approval/Finding and Dismissal of the
Commissioner acting for the Fourth District was heard on September 25, 2009
before a Compensation Review Board panel consisting of the Commission Chairman
John A. Mastropietro and Commissioners Ernie R. Walker and Christine L. Engel.
OPINIONJOHN A. MASTROPIETRO, CHAIRMAN. Both
parties to this claim have petitioned for review from the February 20, 2009
Finding and Approval/Finding and Dismissal of the Commissioner acting for the
Fourth District. Having reviewed the merits of both petitions, we affirm the
decision of the Commissioner.(fn1)
The trial commissioner made the following factual findings which
are pertinent to our review. On March 9, 1999, the claimant, who was employed
by the respondent as a videocommunications specialist, sustained an injury to
his lumbar spine while attempting to maneuver a cart holding a large television
through a set of doorways. In October 1999, James Sabshin, M.D., performed a
L4-5 discectomy, and in March 2006, the claimant underwent a four-level fusion
with Jeffrey Sumner, M.D. Dr. Sumner performed a second fusion in June 2007.
The claimant ultimately came under the care of Rakesh Patel, M.D. for pain
management. The claimant has been totally disabled since the date of the
injury.
Following routine blood work done on March 15, 2006, Dr. Patel
discovered the claimant's testosterone count had fallen well below the normal
range of 350-850, and referred the claimant to Adam Mayerson, M.D., an
endocrinologist. Dr. Mayerson diagnosed the claimant as suffering from
hypogonadism secondary to a combination of a partially empty sella and the
chronic use of narcotic pain medication. Claimant's Exhibit B (Report of
September 15, 2006). In his report of April 24, 2006, Dr. Mayerson stated that
the claimant's "medical history include[d] a condition known as gynecomastia
(male breast enlargement caused by an imbalance of the hormones estrogen and
testosterone) that began in the claimant's early teens."(fn2) Findings, ¶
10. See also Claimant's Exhibit B. Noting that laboratory
results from March 15, 2006 had revealed a total testosterone count of 19, Dr.
Mayerson opined that "[w]hile chronic narcotic use can lead to secondary
hypogonadism, the levels are not typically this low." Claimant's Exhibit B
(Report of April 24, 2006). A subsequent head/cranial MRI performed on April
28, 2006 revealed a "[p]artially empty sella with a thin pituitary gland along
floor of the sella." Claimant's Exhibit B. In his RME report dated October 3,
2008, William Druckemiller, M.D., opined that it was "not absolutely clear how
much the chronic narcotic use contributes to [the claimant's] low testosterone
level. If he did not have an empty sella it would be the causative factor."
Respondents' Exhibit 5, p. 3.
On June 4, 2008, Dr. Patel issued an office note in which he
indicated the claimant was depressed and that he had discussed with the
claimant a referral to a psychiatrist. Claimant's Exhibit H. In his
correspondence of October 2, 2008 to the claimant's physician, Dr. Patel opined
that the claimant's back pain was a substantial contributing factor for
treatment with a psychiatrist. Claimant's Exhibit M. The claimant testified he
had never been formally diagnosed with depression prior to 2005, when Eric
Liben, M.D., a former treating physician, tried to give him some sample
medications for depression. September 4, 2008 Transcript, p. 46. The
evidentiary record also contains a discharge summary pertaining to the March
2006 surgery which indicates the claimant had a prior medical history of
depression.(fn3) Respondents' Exhibit 4. The claimant testified that he did not
know where the diagnosis came from, September 4, 2006 Transcript, p. 47, given
that Dr. Liben's notes are silent relative to a possible diagnosis of
depression because the claimant told him he didn't want a reference to
depression in his records in light of the "stigmata in our society for people
who have mental problems." Id., at 46.
The claimant testified that when he awoke following his second
fusion surgery of June 27, 2007, he experienced numbness, aching and shooting
pain in three fingers of his left hand. Id., at 23. Although the claimant
testified that he told Dr. Sumner about the hand symptoms at several office
visits following the surgery, the doctor "never noted the problem and his
complaints fell on deaf ears."(fn4) Findings, ¶ 24. See
also September 4, 2008 Transcript, pp. 54-55. In his office note of
October 1, 2007, Dr. Sumner indicated he had "inadvertently omitted" to mention
the claimant's left-hand symptoms at the claimant's office visit of September
14, 2007 and noted the claimant believed it was "a function of positioning."
Claimant's Exhibit D. The claimant also testified that he informed Dr. Patel of
the hand symptoms right after the June 27, 2007 surgery, and Dr. Patel opined
that he had probably not been positioned correctly during surgery. September 4,
2008 Transcript, pp. 23-24. Dr. Patel's notes for the claimant's office visits
of August 1, 2007 and October 9, 2007 - the first two office visits following
the claimant's surgery - do not contain a reference to any hand symptoms.
Similarly, Dr. Druckemiller, in his RME report of October 3, 2008, stated that
"[t]he exact etiology of the ulnar nerve symptoms is not documented in the
medical records." Respondents' Exhibit 5, p. 2. Dr. Druckemiller also observed
that "[t]here is no history of onset of numbness in the arm at the time of
surgery. When this happens, it is noted immediately in the hospital and there
is never a question regarding this." Id.
On November 13, 2007, the claimant consulted Mark Altman, M.D.,
who diagnosed the claimant with "ulnar nerve neuropathy arising from the elbow
and probably secondary to compression" and performed ulnar nerve surgery some
time in December 2007. Claimant's Exhibit G. However, on August 29, 2006, the
claimant had apparently consulted an associate of Dr. Altman regarding
bilateral shoulder pain, who reported that "the claimant has had intermittent
numbness in both hands approximately two times each week and that he had been
diagnosed years earlier with carpal tunnel syndrome."(fn5) Findings, ¶ 28.
See also Respondents' Exhibit 2.
The claimant submitted an exhibit documenting...
To continue reading
Request your trial