ADV PR 99-02 (1999).
Case Date | September 07, 1999 |
Court | Rhode Island |
Rhode Island Attorney General Opinions
1999.
ADV PR 99-02 (1999).
State of Rhode
IslandDepartment of the Attorney GeneralADV PR 99-02 (1999)ADV PR 99-02 Narragansett Police Initial Arrest RecordsAdv.
PR 99-02September 7,
1999Mark A. McSally,
EsquirePier Professional TowersNarragansett,
Rhode Island 02882Re:
Narragansett Police Initial Arrest RecordsDear
Mr. McSally:Your letter addressed to Attorney General
Whitehouse has been referred to me for response.In
your capacity as solicitor for the Town of Narragansett, you are requesting an
advisory opinion under Rhode Island's Access to Public Records Act. You relate
that the Narragansett Police Department received a letter from Steven Brown,
Executive Director of the Rhode Island Affiliate of the ACLU, in which he
challenges the Police Department's redaction of names of crime victims from its
public arrest reports. Mr. Brown's letter contends that "arrest reports have
long been deemed public records, and the name of the victim contained in those
reports is no exception." Among other arguments, Mr. Brown asserts that there
is nothing within the Access to Public Records Act which authorizes the
redaction of a victim's name.As I am sure you are
well aware, the Department of the Attorney General, in conjunction with the
Police Chiefs' Association and open records advocates developed procedures and
protocols which police departments could follow in order to facilitate making
public records available to the public. With regard to redacting certain
information contained on public records, the police departments were advised
that there are circumstances where it may redact the name and address of the
victim.As I am sure you are well aware, the purpose
of the Access to Public Records Act is to provide the public with access to
public records while protecting from disclosure information about individuals
maintained that would constitute an unwarranted invasionMark A. McSally, Esq.
September 7, 1999
Page
Twoof personal privacy. Initial arrest reports and
records of an adult are public records; however, the designation as a "public
record" does not foreordain all information contained therein to be
public.Quite to the contrary, pursuant to both
statute and case law, there are circumstances where information, such as an
individual's name, may be redacted from a "public...
To continue reading
Request your trial