ETH 2007-173.
Court | California |
California Ethics Opinion
2007.
ETH 2007-173.
THE STATE BAR OF
CALIFORNIASTANDING COMMITTEE ONPROFESSIONAL
RESPONSIBILITY AND CONDUCTFORMAL OPINION NO. 2007-1732007ISSUES:1. May an attorney, consistent
with ethical obligations, deposit a client's will or other testamentary
documents with a private will depository, without the client's consent?
2. May an attorney, consistent with ethical obligations, register a
client's will or other testamentary documents with a private will registry,
without the client's consent?
DIGEST:
An attorney who retains a client's will or other estate planning
documents on deposit may terminate the deposit in accord with the client's
instructions and/or consent. If the attorney cannot locate the client, the
attorney may only terminate the deposit pursuant to Probate Code section 700,
et seq. An attorney may register certain identifying information about a
client's will or other estate planning documents with a private will registry
if the attorney can determine, based upon knowledge of the client, the client's
matter and investigation of the will registry, that registration will not
violate the attorney's fiduciary duties of confidentiality and
competence.
AUTHORITIES
INTERPRETED:
Rule 3-100 and 3-110 of the Rules of Professional Conduct of the
State Bar of California
Business and Professions Code section 6068, subdivision (a) and
(e) Evidence Code section 912(d)
Probate Code sections 700, et seq.
STATEMENT OF FACTS
In 1973, Attorney drafted a will for Client. At the time,
Attorney and Client agreed that Attorney would retain possession of the
executed original will. By 2003, Attorney is contemplating retirement and would
like to terminate the deposit. However, Attorney has not heard from Client for
25 years, and recent efforts to locate the client have been unsuccessful.
Attorney wants to ensure that Client can obtain access to his will at a future
time or, in the event of his death, that the client's heirs can locate the
will. Therefore, Attorney is considering either depositing the original will
with a private will depository and/or registering certain information about the
will with a private will registry. Attorney's file contains no notes regarding
communications with Client, Attorney has limited recollection of Client, and
has no independent recollection of any communications with Client.
BACKGROUND INFORMATION
Some lawyers who prepare wills or other estate planning documents
retain the original executed documents on deposit for safe-keeping.
Consequently, an attorney who is retiring or becomes unable to continue
practicing law may have original wills and other estate planning documents in
his or her possession. If the attorney can, with reasonable diligence, locate
the former client, the attorney is ethically obligated to do so and to act in
accordance with the client's lawful instructions regarding disposition of the
documents. The more challenging issue is presented when the attorney cannot
locate the former client.
There are two types of commercial enterprises that have recently
started doing business nationally to address these issues: will depositories
and will registries. A will depository is a private, online resource for
locating, storing, and retrieving original wills. A will depository involves
the actual delivery of a will to a central privately operated entity or person
for safekeeping. For purposes of this opinion, a will registry is an online
searchable database of vital information about a will, maintained by a private
entity or person. The information stored in a registry would normally include...
To continue reading
Request your trial