No. 03796088 (1999). EMPLOYEE: Carol Lavoie.
Case Date | March 22, 1999 |
Court | Massachusetts |
Massachusetts Workers Compensation
1999.
No. 03796088 (1999).
EMPLOYEE: Carol Lavoie
COMMONWEALTH OF
MASSACHUSETTS DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL ACCIDENTS EMPLOYEE: Carol Lavoie
EMPLOYER: Zayre Corporation INSURER: Liberty Mutual
Ins. Co.BOARD NO.
03796088REVIEWING BOARD DECISION (Judges Maze-Rothstein, Carroll and
Levine)APPEARANCES
Brian R. Cunha, Esq., for the Employee at hearing
Honey Polner, Esq., for the Employee on brief
Paul J. Burke, Esq., for the Insurer at hearing
Thomas G. Brophy, Esq., for the Insurer at hearing
Andrew P. Saltis, Esq., for the Insurer on brief
MAZE-ROTHSTEIN, J. The insurer appeals
a decision awarding the employee G.L.c. 152, § 35, weekly partial
incapacity benefits, based on subsidiary findings of total incapacity. The
employee's entitlement to § 34 temporary total incapacity weekly benefits
had exhausted prior to the filing date of the decision. (Dec. 19.) The insurer
contends that the award of partial incapacity benefits lacked the necessary
evidentiary support. We disagree, because we consider that the judge had the
equitable authority to make such a weekly benefits award. We affirm the
decision.
The employee, Carol Lavoie, was fifty-four years old at the time
the hearing record was re-opened in 1995. (Dec. 4.) 1 After completing high
school, she worked as a stitcher, secretary, waitress, occupational therapist
assistant, house cleaner and as a substitute teacher. (Dec. 4.) For the
employer, Zayre Corporation, she worked as an overnight stock clerk. Her duties
included loading and unloading delivery trucks and stocking merchandise on
shelves. (Dec. 4-5.)
On June 10, 1988, while unloading a truck, an air conditioner box
slipped from the employee's hand and struck the inner aspect of her left knee
as it fell. (Dec. 5.) She stopped work immediately due to pain in the left
knee. She treated conservatively until November 1988, when arthroscopic surgery
was performed on her knee. (Employee Ex. 3, p. 11; Dec. 5, 9.)
Post-operatively, the pain did not abate. The employee was then referred for
pain management treatment. (Dec. 5.)
Ms. Lavoie's recovery effort has spanned a number of years and an
array of treatment modalities including: acupuncture, sympathetic blocks,
steroid injections, surgical removal of a sympathetic nerve ganglion, physical
therapy and various medications. (Dec. 5-8.)
The...
To continue reading
Request your trial