No. 05193295 (1999). EMPLOYEE: Steven Delaney.
Case Date | March 09, 1999 |
Court | Massachusetts |
Massachusetts Workers Compensation
1999.
No. 05193295 (1999).
EMPLOYEE: Steven Delaney
COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS
DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL ACCIDENTS EMPLOYEE: Steven Delaney EMPLOYER: Laidlaw Waste
Systems INSURER: National Union Fire Ins. Co.BOARD NO. 05193295REVIEWING BOARD DECISION (Judges McCarthy, Smith and Wilson)APPEARANCES
Tanya P. Millett, Esq., for the employee
Maryann Calnan, Esq., for the insurer
MCCARTHY, J. The insurer appeals a
§ 11 hearing decision in which the employee was awarded weekly § 34
benefits, medical expenses under § 30, attorney fees and costs for the
deposition of the impartial medical examiner. The insurer contends that the
judge's finding that the employee is totally incapacitated is arbitrary and not
supported by the evidence presented. We disagree and therefore affirm the
decision.
At the time of the hearing, Steven Delaney was forty-two years of
age, married with two minor children, and lived in Weymouth, Massachusetts. Mr.
Delaney is a high school graduate with training as a mechanic. (Dec. 2.) He was
employed by Laidlaw Waste Systems for eighteen years, most recently as a truck
mechanic. His job responsibilities included the frequent lifting of 150 pounds
or more and climbing and crawling over and around trucks as needed to perform
the required mechanical work. (Dec. 3.)
On December 7, 1995, while repairing the wiring on a trash truck,
the employee felt a muscle spasm and heard a "scrunching" noise, like an
electric shock, in his back and leg. (Dec. 3.) He reported the incident to the
shop supervisor and continued to work the remainder of his shift. After the
workday was completed, Delaney went home to soak in a tub and rest. He returned
the next day and completed his responsibilities despite being in pain. The
employee rested over the weekend and returned to work on Monday. However, he
experienced pain and contacted his doctor from the work site. An appointment
was made for the following day. The employee's doctor advised two weeks bed
rest and prescribed muscle relaxants. The employee has not returned to work
since. (Dec. 3.) Mr. Delaney was referred to Dr. DiTullio who then scheduled
the employee for various diagnostic tests. In February 1996, the employee
underwent low back disc surgery at South Shore Hospital. Following the
operation, the employee had a course of physical therapy...
To continue reading
Request your trial